Skip to main content
Turtle Lake Tap & Grill logo top - HomepageTurtle Lake Tap & Grill logo scroll - Homepage
  • (262)-458-0342
  • tltapandgrill@gmail.com
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Jobs
  • About
  • Reserve
  • Gift Cards
  • Pier Rental
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
Turtle Lake Tap & Grill logo top - HomepageTurtle Lake Tap & Grill logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Jobs
  • About
  • Reserve
  • Gift Cards
  • Pier Rental

Our Menu

  • Menu
  • Weekend Specials

Appetizers

Truffle Fries
$9.99

Basket of crispy beer-battered fries tossed with truffle oil, parmesan & served with garlic aioli

Baked Stuffed Jalapeños
$11.99

Fresh jalapeños stuffed with our cream cheese Italian sausage blend, cheddar cheese & breadcrumbs

Baked Stuffed Mushrooms
$11.99

Just like our famous stuffed jalapeños, but with mushrooms!

1 Lb. Giant Pretzel
$13.99

Giant Bavarian pretzel served with side of homemade beer cheese dipping sauce

Chicken Tenders
$11.99

Hand-breaded & fried, served with house ranch or BBQ. Choice of plain or spicy

Cheese Curds
$9.99

Wisconsin white cheddar curds, fried & served with ranch

Travis’s Wings
$9.99

Chicken wings served plain, buffalo or BBQ

Nachos
$11.99

Smoked pulled pork, creamy queso, lettuce, tomato, jalapeños, pickled red onion, sour cream & a drizzle of BBQ

Spinach Artichoke Dip
$11.99

Creamy cheese blend with spinach & marinated artichoke hearts. Served warm with choice of fresh tortilla or pita chips

Chips & Queso
$11.99

Creamy queso serviced with fresh homemade tortilla chips

Pizza

12" pizza on our homemade dough. Can be substituted with a 10" cauliflower crust for additional $5.00

Steak Au Blue
$15.99

Fresh mozzarella and grilled steak over a garlic aioli base, topped with blue cheese & caramelized onions

Caprese
$14.99

Fresh mozzarella cheese and tomato over a garlic aioli base, topped with balsamic & pesto drizzle

Hawaiian
$13.99

Mozzarella cheese over a barbecue base, topped with pineapple, bacon & red onion

Cheese
$13.99

Fresh mozzarella cheese over a homemade marinara base

Pepperoni
$15.99

Fresh mozzarella cheese over a homemade marinara base, & covered in pepperoni

Sausage
$15.99

Fresh mozzarella cheese and hand-pulled sausage over a homemade marinara base

Build Your Own
$13.99

• Protein choices (1): Pepperoni, sausage, steak, chicken or bacon – add $1.50 per item
• Veggie choices (3): Mushroom, raw onion, pineapple, caramelized onion, green pepper, tomato, black olive, green olive, jalapeños – add $0.75 per item
• Sauce choices (1 included): Marinara, Garlic Aioli, or BBQ
• Cheese (1 included): Comes with fresh mozzarella. Add blue cheese, cheddar, or parmesan – add $1.00

Burgers

Served on a potato roll. Alternative choices - gluten free bun, or on a bed of mixed greens

Texas Hold ‘Em
$15.99

1/2lb beef patty topped with smoked bacon, jalapeño jam, caramelized onion, cheddar, lettuce, tomato & fried egg

Bacon Blue
$14.99

1/2lb beef patty topped with blue cheese & smoked bacon

TL Burger
$12.99

1/2lb beef patty topped with choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato & onion

Mushroom Swiss
$14.99

1/2lb beef patty topped with sauteed mushrooms & melted Swiss cheese

Tex-Mex
$15.99

1/2lb beef patty topped with cheddar, jalapeño, guacamole & smokey aioli

Sandwiches

Alternative bread choices - sourdough, seeded wheat, potato bun, ciabatta, marbled rye or gluten free bun

Chicken Salad Sandwich
$14.99

Smoked chicken, tossed with celery, onion, tangy mayo, lettuce & tomato on sourdough

Beach Club
$12.99

Smoked turkey with hummus, thick-cut bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato & basil mayo on seeded wheat

Turkey Club
$12.99

Smoked turkey, tomato, cheddar, ham, thick-cut bacon, lettuce & garlic mayo on marbled rye

Hawaiian Chicken
$14.99

Grilled or crispy chicken breast topped with ham, provolone, grilled pineapple & smokey aioli

TL Chicken
$12.99

Chicken breast (grilled or crispy). Traditional: lettuce, tomato, onion & cheese. Spicy: pepper jack, pickled onion, dill pickles & hot sauce

Pulled Pork
$12.99

Smoked pulled pork, coleslaw, pickled red onion, Fresno chiles & jalapeño mayo on ciabatta

Spicy TL Chicken
$12.99

Grilled or crispy chicken topped with pepper jack cheese, pickled onion, dill pickles & smothered in hot sauce

Philly Cheesesteak
$16.99

8oz sirloin steak mixed with grilled onion & green bell pepper, smothered with mozzarella atop a French baguette

Spicy TL Chicken
$12.99

Grilled or crispy chicken topped with pepper jack cheese, pickled onion, dill pickles & smothered in hot sauce

Fish BLT
$16.99

Fried fish, lettuce, tomato, bacon, avocado & basil mayo on French bread

Cubano
$13.99

Smoked pulled pork, ham, Swiss, pickles & mustard chipotle mayo on ciabatta

Muffaletta
$14.99

Smoked turkey, provolone, wilted spinach, olive relish and garlic mayo on ciabatta

Southwest Chicken
$14.99

Chicken breast (grilled or crispy) topped with jalapeño, guacamole, cheddar cheese and smokey aioli

Salads & Wraps

Classic Caesar
$13.99

Chopped romaine, crispy shallots, shaved parmesan, croutons & creamy Caesar dressing

Mediterranean
$13.99

Chopped romaine topped with tomatoes, red onion, feta, cucumbers, kalamata olives & lemon oregano vinaigrette

Cobb
$13.99

Chopped romaine topped with tomatoes, bacon, onion, egg, avocado, blue cheese & ranch

Caprese
$13.99

Mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, crispy onions, balsamic vinaigrette

ADD PROTEIN TO ANY SALAD OR WRAP

• Chicken (grilled or crispy) or Smoked Turkey | $2.99
• Hard-boiled egg | $1.00

DRESSING CHOICES:

Ranch, Blue Cheese, French, Lemon Oregano Vinaigrette, Balsamic Vinaigrette, or Caesar

Quesadillas

Custom blend of melted cheeses, served with smokey aioli & fresh pico de gallo. Add a side of fries, house made pub chips, side salad or coleslaw - $2.50

Cheese
$9.99
Chicken
$11.99
Steak
$13.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch
$13.99

Chicken, bacon and you guessed it, ranch!

Little Turtles

Served with fries or house made pub chips

Chicken Tenders
$8.99
Burger
$8.99
Cheese Quesadilla
$8.99
Mac & Cheese
$8.99

Sides

Fries
$4.99
Pub Chips
$5.99
Tots
$4.99
Side Salad
$5.99
Coleslaw
$3.99

Dessert

Vanilla Cheesecake
$6.00

Enjoy as is, or with chocolate, caramel or raspberry drizzle

Raspberry Lemon Drop Cake
$7.50

Yellow sponge cake, lemon mousse, raspberry preserves

Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich
$7.00

Filled with vanilla buttercream

Peanut Butter Explosion Cake
$7.50

Chocolate cake, peanut butter mousse, fudge brownies

Specials

Thursday

$15 Date Night Wine

Friday Fish Fry

Dinner served with choice of chips, fries or potato pancakes. Includes house-made coleslaw, tarter sauce, warm dinner roll, butter & lemon.
• 3-PIECE COD DINNER (BAKED OR FRIED) $20.99 - Icelandic cod, hand breaded & fried crispy or rubbed with seasoned butter & baked
• 4-PIECE PERCH DINNER $21.99 - Lake perch, hand-breaded & fried crispy
• 8-PIECE JUMBO FRIED SHRIMP DINNER $20.99 - Hand-breaded & fried crispy

Saturday

Rotating Dinner Specials
Ask about our fried shrimp tacos!

Sunday

$20 Bottomless Mimosas
$6 Bloody Mary

  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Jobs